Silver Wedding Rings: Pros, Cons, and How They Compare to Gold and Platinum

Traditional yellow gold wedding rings handcrafted in 9ct gold

Silver is often passed over in favour of gold or platinum when choosing wedding rings, but does it have to be? How does silver compare when we consider the pros and cons?

If you’re considering a silver wedding ring, you’re not alone. I’m asked about them often, and I’ve made silver wedding bands for many couples who are looking for something more affordable - but also something handmade, considered, and lasting. As the cost of gold and platinum continues to rise, silver is becoming a popular choice.

Sterling silver (925) is a reliable, workable metal that lends itself well to handcrafting and detailed finishes. I use 100% recycled sterling silver for all of my rings, shaped and finished by hand in my studio. It suits people who care about craft, sustainability, and simplicity.

My husband wears a silver wedding band I made for him over twelve years ago, and it still looks fantastic - naturally worn, but solid and full of character.

Are Silver Wedding Rings Durable Enough for Everyday Wear?

The main reason silver wedding rings aren’t as commonly seen in traditional jewellers is simple: silver is softer than gold or platinum.

This means your ring is more likely to pick up scratches and small marks as it’s worn. A high polish won’t hold its mirror finish forever - it will dull a little with time. Textured or matte finishes can help soften the impact of wear, but a silver ring will change with you. Some people love that, many don’t, and so gold and platinum reigns.

Silver can also bend more easily if the band is too thin or lightweight. A lighter weight design that works well in gold might not translate directly to silver. If you’re choosing silver for your wedding ring, it’s important to go for a solid, well-proportioned design that can handle everyday life.

So, if you work with your hands or want a ring that stays pristine for decades, silver might not be your best option. However, if you like the idea of a ring that develops character over time - one that reflects your day-to-day life - silver can be a thoughtful, wearable and affordable choice.

Comparing Silver, Gold and Platinum Wedding Rings

Gold (in both 9ct and 18ct) is harder than silver and tends to resist wear more effectively. 9ct gold, in particular, has a slightly higher proportion of alloy metals, which makes it more durable than 18ct, though it can be more prone to very slight tarnish over time. Gold also comes in a variety of colours - yellow, rose, and white - and has a long history of being used in wedding jewellery. It costs more, but for many, the resilience and heritage justify the investment.

Platinum is extremely durable, hypoallergenic, and significantly heavier. It’s the most expensive option, often chosen for its strength and status. I don’t personally offer platinum, as my focus is on recycled silver and gold, both of which allow for a more flexible, handmade approach.

Silver doesn’t try to compete with those. It offers something different: a way to wear a ring that feels honest, handmade, and uncomplicated. For many people, that’s exactly what they want.

Is White Gold a Good Alternative to Silver?

You might want to consider white gold if you're looking for that similar colour and superior durability. It offers a similar tone to silver but with greater resistance to scratching and wear.

That said, most white gold rings on the high street are rhodium plated to give them a bright white finish. Over time, this plating wears off and needs to be reapplied - often every year or two - something many people only discover later.

I don’t rhodium plate when I work with white gold. I work with the natural colour of white gold, which has a slightly warmer, softer tone than silver. It’s a good option if you like a subtle finish and want something stronger than silver but without the upkeep of plating.

Is a Silver Wedding Ring Right for You?

Silver wedding rings are becoming increasingly popular - not only because they’re more affordable, but because many people want something handmade and personal. For some, it’s a way to step away from generic, mass-produced jewellery and instead choose a piece that reflects their values.

A textured silver band with enough weight to last a lifetime

Silver wedding rings can suit people who value meaning over marketing. If you want something made with care, from recycled materials, and shaped to reflect your style and life, silver is a strong and honest choice.

If you’re still unsure, feel free to explore my collection of handmade silver rings - or get in touch to talk about what you’re looking for.